Chapter 19

CHAPTER 19 Shocked and angry caterwauls rose up from the cats surrounding the Great Rock. Every muscle in Fireheart's body urged him to creep backward into the bushes and hide from their fury. It took all his strength to stay where he was. Sandstorm pressed against his side, as shaken as he was, and he found her warmth comforting. On top of the Great Rock, Tallstar whipped around to face Bluestar. "Is this true?" he snarled. Bluestar did not reply to him at once. With great dignity, she stepped forward and faced Nightstar. The moonlight glowed on her fur, turning it to silver, so that Fireheart could almost believe that a warrior of StarClan had leaped down from Silverpelt to join them. She waited until the noise from below had died down. "How do you know this?" she coolly asked Nightstar when she could make herself heard. "Have you been spying on our camp?" "Spying!" Nightstar spat the word out. "There's no need to spy when your apprentices gossip so freely. My warriors heard this at the last Gathering. Do you dare to stand here now and tell

me they are wrong?" As he spoke, Fireheart remembered seeing Swiftpaw with the ShadowClan apprentices at the end of the last Gathering. No wonder the young cat had looked guilty, if he had been telling his friends all about ThunderClan's prisoner, so soon after Bluestar had ordered all her Clan to keep quiet! Bluestar hesitated. Fireheart felt a pang of sympathy for her. Many of her own Clan had been unhappy with her decision to shelter blind Brokentail. How was she going to defend herself in front of the other Clans? Tallstar crouched in front of her, his ears flattened. "Is it true?" he repeated. For a moment Bluestar did not speak. Then she lifted her head defiantly. "Yes, it's true," she meowed. "Traitor!" spat Tallstar. "You know what Brokenstar did to us." Bluestar's tail tip twitched; even from his place below the rock Fireheart could see the strain in every muscle of her body, and knew she was struggling to keep calm. "No cat dares to call me

traitor!" she hissed. "I dare," retorted Tallstar. "You are nothing but a traitor to the warrior code, if you are willing to give shelter to that…that heap of foxdung!" All around the clearing WindClan cats leaped to their paws, yowling in support of their leader. "Traitor! Traitor!" At the foot of the Great Rock, Tigerclaw and Deadfoot, the WindClan deputy, faced each other with their hackles raised, lips drawn back to show their sharp teeth, their noses no more than a mouse-length apart. Fireheart sprang up too, his fighting instinct sending energy to his paws. He caught a glimpse of Willowpelt snarling at the WindClan queens with whom she had been sharing tongues a few moments before. A couple of ShadowClan warriors paced threateningly toward Darkstripe, and Mousefur leaped to his side, ready to attack. "Stop!" Bluestar yowled from her place on the Great Rock. "How can you break the truce like this? Would you risk the wrath of StarClan?" As she spoke, the moonlight began to fade. Every cat in the clearing froze. Looking up,

Fireheart saw a wisp of cloud passing over the face of the moon. He shivered. Was that a warning from StarClan, because the Clans seemed about to break the sacred truce? Clouds had covered the moon once before, a sign of StarClan's anger that had brought the Gathering to an end. As the cloud passed away the moonlight strengthened again. The moment of crisis had passed. Most of the cats sat down, though they continued to glare at one another. Whitestorm pushed himself between Deadfoot and Tigerclaw, and started to mew urgently into the ThunderClan deputy's ear. On the top of the Great Rock, Crookedstar stepped forward to stand beside Bluestar. He looked calm; Fireheart realized that of all the Clans, RiverClan had least reason to hate Brokentail. He had not crossed the river into their territory, or stolen their kits. "Bluestar," he meowed, "tell us why you have done this." "Brokentail is blind," Bluestar replied, her voice ringing out so that every cat in the clearing could hear her. "He is an old, defeated cat. He is

no danger, not anymore. Would you have him starve to death in the forest?" "Yes!" Nightstar's voice rose, shrill and insistent. "No death is too cruel for him!" Flecks of foam spun from the ShadowClan leader's lips. He thrust his head aggressively toward Tallstar and snarled, "Will you forgive the cat who drove you out?" For a moment Fireheart wondered why Nightstar should be so frantic, so intent on whipping up Tallstar's hatred like this. He was Clan leader now. What harm could a blind prisoner do him? Tallstar flinched away from the ShadowClan leader, clearly taken aback by his fury. "You know how much this means to my Clan," he meowed. "We will never forgive Brokenstar." "Then I tell you, you're wrong," meowed Bluestar. "The warrior code tells us to show compassion. Tallstar, don't you remember what ThunderClan did for you when you were defeated and driven out? We found you and brought you home, and later we fought beside you against RiverClan. Have you forgotten what you owe us?"

Far from soothing Tallstar, Bluestar's words angered the WindClan leader more than ever. He stalked up to her, his fur bristling. "Does ThunderClan claim to own us?" he spat out. "Is that why you brought us back, to bow to your wishes and accept your decisions without question? Do you think WindClan has no honor?" Bluestar bowed her head in the face of the WindClan leader's fury. "Tallstar," she meowed. "You're right that no Clan can own another. That's not what I meant. But remember how you felt when you were weak, and try to show compassion now. If we drive Brokentail out to die, we're no better than he is." "Compassion?" spat Nightstar. "Don't give us tales fit for kits, Bluestar! What compassion did Brokenstar ever show?" Yowls of agreement filled the air as he spoke. Nightstar added, "You must drive him out now, Bluestar, or I'll want to know the reason why." Bluestar's eyes narrowed to glittering blue slits. "Don't tell me how to run my Clan!" "I'll tell you this," Nightstar growled. "If ThunderClan keeps on sheltering Brokenstar, you